Key takeaways
- Find the best cookie cutters for sugar cookies, biscuits, and holiday baking. Compare five sets by material, size range, storage, and ease of use.
A good cookie cutter does one simple job: it presses through dough and leaves a clean edge that holds its shape in the oven. When the edge is sharp and the rim is tall enough, a sugar cookie comes out with crisp lines that are easy to decorate. When the edge is dull or the rim is shallow, the dough tears, the shape spreads, and the finished cookie looks nothing like the cutter that made it.
This guide compares five sets that cover the main ways people bake: a graduated round set for biscuits, a fluted round set for scones, a large plastic set for letters and numbers, a metal holiday set for seasonal trays, and a graduated heart set for gifts. Each set lists the specifications that could be verified, with anything unconfirmed marked as not stated.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Answer
For most home bakers, the Ateco 5457 plain round set is the best place to begin, because twelve graduated stainless rounds cover biscuits, scones, doughnuts, and plain sugar cookies all year. Add the Wilton 101-piece set when you need letters, numbers, and holiday shapes, and keep a small metal holiday set on hand for seasonal trays.
Best Cookie Cutters
Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece
The Ateco 5457 is the workhorse of this guide. Twelve graduated stainless steel rounds run from roughly 7/8 inch to about 4 3/8 inches, and each cutter stands 1 1/4 inches tall. That depth matters: a biscuit rolled to three-quarters of an inch needs a rim taller than the dough, or the dough folds over the top edge instead of being cut cleanly. Stainless steel holds a sharp edge and does not rust when left wet, and the cutters nest inside their own storage tin. The same ladder cuts biscuits, scones, dumpling wrappers, and tart bases, so this set gets used all year.
The limitation is that rounds are only rounds. This set makes no shapes, so a baker who wants gingerbread men or letters still needs a shape set. For everyday baking, though, no other set here gets used as often.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 12 |
| Material | Stainless steel |
| Size range | Approx. 7/8 to 4 3/8 in |
| Cutting depth | 1 1/4 in |
| Storage | Nesting tin included |
| Care | Not stated |
Wilton Plastic Cookie Cutters, 101-Piece
The Wilton 101-piece set is the variety pick. It holds a hundred and one plastic cutters in a storage pail, including the full alphabet and numbers alongside animals, holiday icons, and everyday shapes. That alphabet is the reason to buy it: no metal set here includes letters or numbers. Plastic is kinder to small hands, which makes this the set children reach for first. Each cutter measures about 3 1/2 by 3 1/2 inches on average, so the variety is in the shapes, not in graduated sizes.
The trade-off is the cutting edge. Plastic does not cut chilled, stiff dough as cleanly as a stainless rim, and it cannot be sharpened if it flexes. Wilton’s own care instruction is to wash the cutters in warm soapy water and dry them thoroughly, while some retailer listings call the set dishwasher safe. Follow Wilton’s instruction, because a dishwasher drying cycle is exactly how thin plastic cutters warp.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 101 |
| Material | Plastic |
| Average cutter size | Approx. 3 1/2 by 3 1/2 in |
| Letters and numbers | Full alphabet and numbers included |
| Storage | Storage pail included |
| Care | Warm soapy water, dry thoroughly |
Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece
The Ateco 5307 is the fluted companion to the plain round set above. Eleven graduated stainless rounds run from 3/4 inch to 3 1/4 inches, and the crimped edge is not decoration. The flutes give a biscuit or scone more surface to climb as it rises, and they hide the slight raggedness a plain cut can leave in a soft, high-fat dough, which is why the fluted edge is the traditional cut for scones and jam tarts. Like the plain set, they are stainless steel, stand 1 1/4 inches tall, and nest into their own round tin.
Two things deserve a note. First, retailers publish two different top sizes, 3 1/4 inches and 3.5 inches, so the largest cutter is not settled; this article uses the 3 1/4 inch figure. Second, a fluted edge is wrong for anything that must stack or glaze flat, so this is a second set, not a first one.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 11 |
| Material | Stainless steel |
| Size range | 3/4 to 3 1/4 in |
| Cutting depth | 1 1/4 in |
| Storage | Round tin included |
| Care | Not stated |
Wilton Holiday 18 pc Metal Cookie Cutter Set
The Wilton Holiday 18-piece set is the seasonal pick for a baker who decorates cookies once or twice a year and wants one box that covers it. Eighteen metal cutters cover the classic holiday shapes: reindeer, wreath, angel, snowflake, Santa, leaf, candy, tree, and bell. One set supplies a whole Christmas tray without buying a separate cutter for each design. Metal holds an edge better than plastic and does not bend in stiff gingerbread dough, and eighteen cutters let several people cut at the same table.
The limitation is focus. Every shape here points at the holidays, so a baker who wants hearts or bunnies still needs another set. The listing does not publish individual cutter sizes, so each size is not stated here. Dry metal cutters thoroughly after washing, because a coated edge can spot if put away damp.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 18 |
| Material | Metal |
| Shapes | Reindeer, wreath, angel, snowflake, Santa, leaf, candy, tree, bell |
| Individual sizes | Not stated |
| Storage | Not stated |
| Care | Not stated |
Fox Run Heart Shaped Cookie Cutters, 5-Piece Set
The Fox Run heart set is the budget pick and the most useful single-shape set in this guide. Five graduated stainless steel hearts come in a storage tin, and the heart is a shape that works far beyond one holiday. It suits Valentine’s Day, weddings, baby showers, and any tray that needs a friendly shape. A heart reads clearly at any size and decorates easily. Stainless steel survives being left wet and cuts chilled dough cleanly, and a small heart can top a cupcake while a large one anchors a cookie tray.
The trade-off is scope. Five hearts are five hearts, and a baker who wants a full holiday collection needs a bigger set. The listing does not publish the individual diameters, so the size range is not stated here.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 5 |
| Material | Stainless steel |
| Shape | Heart, graduated sizes |
| Individual sizes | Not stated |
| Storage | Storage tin included |
| Care | Not stated |
How to Choose
Start with material, because it decides how a cutter behaves. Stainless steel holds the sharpest edge, keeps its shape under pressure, and resists rust when left wet. Tinplate steel is cheaper but rusts once its coating is scratched or the cutter is put away damp. Aluminum is soft and goes oval with use. Plastic is light and safe for children, but it cannot be sharpened and it does not cut chilled, stiff dough as cleanly as metal.
Next, check the cutting depth. A biscuit rolled to three-quarters of an inch needs a rim taller than the dough, or the dough folds over the top edge. A rim around 1 1/4 inches tall clears most biscuit and scone dough, while shallow cutters near half an inch suit thin sugar cookies and fondant.
Then look at whether the sizes form a ladder. A graduated set beats a random assortment, because the answer to a cutter that is slightly too big is the next one down. Finally, match the set to the baking you do: rounds first for weekly baking, a metal holiday set for seasonal trays, and letters only when you spell names on birthday trays.
Who Should Skip It
A baker who never rolls dough does not need a cutter set at all. Drop cookies, bar cookies, and scooped cookies need no cutter; a scoop or a press serves those recipes better. If every cookie you bake is a drop cookie, skip this whole category and spend the drawer space elsewhere.
A baker with a very small kitchen should also think twice before buying the 101-piece set. A hundred cutters need a pail of their own, and a set that lives in a crowded drawer gets crushed. A crushed cutter cuts a crushed shape forever. In a small kitchen, one nesting round set and one small shape set cover nearly everything. Anyone who bakes only once a year for a single holiday can skip the big sets too: a single themed set does the job with far less storage.
FAQ
Do metal cookie cutters rust?
Tinplate steel cutters can rust if stored damp, because the thin coating scratches and exposes the steel underneath. Stainless steel resists rust far better, which is why the Ateco and Fox Run sets in this guide use it. Whatever the material, wash cutters by hand and dry them fully before storing.
What size cookie cutter should I buy first?
A set of graduated rounds is the best first buy, because rounds cover biscuits, scones, doughnuts, and plain sugar cookies. A ladder from under an inch to over four inches handles nearly every round recipe. Add shape sets later, once you know which occasions you bake for.
Can children use cookie cutters safely?
Yes, with the right set. Plastic cutters are the safest choice for young children, because the edges are not sharp enough to cut skin and the cutters are light. Metal cutters are fine for older children with supervision, and a set with a rolled top edge is kinder to small hands than a raw steel rim.
How do I keep cutters from sticking to the dough?
Chill the dough before cutting, and roll it on a lightly floured surface or between sheets of parchment. If the dough sticks and tears, it is usually too warm; return it to the refrigerator for a short rest. Dip the cutter in flour between cuts, and lift straight up instead of twisting.
Final Verdict
The best cookie cutters are the ones that match the baking you do most. For most home bakers, the Ateco 5457 plain round set is the right first buy: twelve graduated stainless rounds, a tall cutting edge, and a storage tin cover biscuits, scones, and everyday cookies all year. Add the Ateco 5307 fluted set for scones, the Wilton 101-piece set for letters and holiday shapes, the Wilton Holiday 18-piece set for seasonal trays, and the Fox Run heart set for any gathering.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Send a Prime gift membership to someone who would use free shipping and Prime Video.
Gift Amazon PrimeGive audiobooks to someone who loves to listen. Plans and prices are set by Amazon.
Gift AudibleSet up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveCollect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.
Create a wedding registryAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!